First Impressions Read online

“Great,” he said, smiling, and Eden smiled back. She gathered her things and stood up. “Tell me, Mr. Granville, is your daughter for or against your dating? I couldn’t tell by her expression.”

  “Very much for it. She says that I’m a helpless man without a wife, so she wants to marry me off.”

  He looked at Eden so hard, with so much intention, that she blushed.

  “Well, ah…” she said nervously. “Uh, I’ll…come tomorrow at six. I’ll probably have a hundred questions to ask you by then.”

  “Great,” he said, standing and walking her to the door. “I look forward to it.”

  Eden thought that he wanted to say more, but there was someone waiting to see him, so he had to let them into his office. She gave a quick glance at the unsmiling Camden, then hurried from the office. She didn’t want to give the young woman time to ask her any more questions.

  Once outside, Eden got into her cheap rental car and headed toward the grocery store. But things had changed in twenty-two years, and the grocery she used to go to had been replaced by a car dealership. She thought she’d just stop in and ask for directions, but two hours later she’d leased a small SUV. By the time she’d had lunch (North Carolina barbecue) and had explored a few shops downtown, it was nearly four o’clock. After she’d filled her new car with groceries, it was growing dark. She wondered if she’d purposefully postponed seeing the house until late just so she wouldn’t be able to spend much time there. She thought she’d put the groceries away, then go back to spend the night at the bed-and-breakfast. She’d not even asked if the electricity had been turned on in the house, so it would be better to postpone staying.

  Even though Farrington Manor had once been the plantation house for a farm that covered over a thousand acres, the house was very close to downtown Arundel. Eden drove to the end of King Street, took a left onto Water Street, drove past the lush Braddon Park, then turned right over the narrow wooden bridge that took her to Farrington Manor. As she drove she saw two small houses on the left, built since she’d lived there and now pretty with flowers and ten-year-old trees. She saw that the old house that had once been the overseer’s had been completely renovated.

  On the left lay open fields that were leased to local farmers to grow peanuts, cotton, milo, or soybeans, but on the right was parkland of enormous, mature hardwood trees. Some of the trees that she’d come to know were now missing, felled by hurricanes. “God’s way of pruning,” Mrs. Farrington used to say. The high winds used to terrify Eden, but Mrs. Farrington and Melissa took them in stride, playing endless games of checkers by candlelight.

  When Eden got close enough such that she knew in the next moment the house was going to come into view, she turned off her headlights and coasted forward, her arms on the steering wheel. First a chimney, then the roof came into view. Right away she saw that the house was in better repair than it had been years ago. Eden remembered the story of the silver teapot by Paul Revere. Had Mrs. Farrington known that she had such a teapot? Or had she pulled everything from under the floorboards and taken it all to a dealer?

  Smiling with happy memories, Eden looked at the house in the moonlight. It was two stories, flat fronted, with two rows of seven eight-paned windows. At one point in its long history, the house had had double porches and a door out from the second story, but when a hurricane had badly damaged the top porch, Mrs. Farrington’s father had removed it. Now there was one wide porch along the lower front.

  Still smiling, Eden moved forward, her tires barely rolling. Suddenly, she stopped. There was a light moving about upstairs. A flashlight. Someone was inside the house!

  So now what do I do? she wondered. Call the sheriff? And what if he comes out to the house, sirens blazing, only to find out that the person inside the house was a neighbor? Or maybe it was Braddon Granville. He’d had time enough to finish with his clients, so maybe he’d decided to visit her. The thought made Eden smile. She’d liked him and had been flattered by his frank admiration of her. In the years she’d lived in New York she’d spent many hours in a gym in order to give Melissa and Stuart time alone. Movies, the gym, and working on her book. Those things had taken up a lot of her time in the last years, but today Braddon Granville had made her glad of every sit-up and leg lift. She was proud of the fact that she was the same size as when she’d lived in Arundel so long ago. Having a baby when she was so young and her skin so elastic meant that she’d been able to regain her twenty-four-inch waist.

  Eden parked her car under a tree, out of sight of the windows of the house, and quietly made her way to the front door. She tried the old doorknob. It was locked. Maybe he went in through the kitchen door, she thought as she used her key to silently unlock the door. She could call out to the person as she set her things down, but she well knew how isolated the house was. No, it would be better to be cautious. Above her head, a floorboard creaked then stopped, as though the person making the sound didn’t want to be heard. That sneaking made her forget her good thoughts. Whoever was in the house shouldn’t be there—and knew it.

  Eden stepped out on the porch and pulled her cell phone out of her handbag. She didn’t think about what she was doing when she called, not the sheriff, but Braddon Granville. He answered on the first ring.

  “Eden!” he said, his voice full of pleasure at her call. “Did you change your mind about tonight? We could have dinner at—”

  “Someone’s in my house,” she said.

  “I’m sorry but I can’t hear you.”

  Eden tiptoed down the porch steps and went toward her car. “Someone is in my house,” she said louder so she could be heard above the frogs. “He’s upstairs with a flashlight.”

  There was a pause on the phone, then the voice of a man in charge. “Get out of there right now,” he said in a tone that was not to be disobeyed. “Get in your car and return to town. I’m going to call the sheriff, and he’ll be there as fast as possible, but I want you out of there. Understand me?”

  “Yes,” she said, her heart pounding. She already had the door to the car open but then realized that she’d left her car keys inside the house. She started to tell Mr. Granville that, but he’d already hung up to call the sheriff.

  Now what? Did she crouch in the bushes and wait in silence for the cavalry to come and save her? Or did she go back into the house, get her car keys, then roar away in a torrent of gravel?

  Turning back to the house, Eden looked up at the windows and saw nothing. No moving light. What if all she’d seen had been a reflection of the moon? Had she been so spooked by Braddon Granville’s story of Mrs. Farrington’s evil son that she’d made something ordinary into something sinister? She called Mr. Granville’s office again but got his machine. She was going to look really stupid when half a dozen police cars arrived and the only intruder was a reflection on the windows of a creaking old house.

  Okay, better to face this on her own, she thought, or she was going to be the town’s source of laughter for years to come. Taking a deep breath, she went up the stairs to the front porch and opened the door. She had intended to call out and ask if anyone was there, but as soon as she was inside she again heard the floorboards creak, only this time, the sound came from the living room.

  On tiptoe, Eden crept toward the doorway. Thank heaven that most of the furniture had been sold or she never would have been able to make her way in silence. If the house were still as full of furniture as when Mrs. Farrington was alive, Eden would have had to crawl over and under surfaces to get there.

  As it was, when she got to the doorway, she crouched down low, then looked around the doorframe. She could see a man’s silhouette clearly outlined. He had a small flashlight, just a penlight really. If he were on the up and up he’d have a full-size flashlight, wouldn’t he? Eden’s intuition told her that this man was looking for something. For the silverware that she and Mrs. Farrington had hidden inside the walls? For that blasted necklace that had been in every Lost Treasures book ever written?

  Suddenly, from